Edmonton fans pack the Monday mailbag questioning if Calvin Pickard drew the short straw in his Oilers tenure amid goaltending carousel drama. GMs rarely air regrets publicly, but whispers from the room suggest mismanagement cost a gem. As the deadline nears, this debate shapes roster moves for a contender desperate for net stability.

Calvin Pickard finds himself in the odd spot of third-string goalie for the Oilers, then hits waivers right before the 2026 Winter Olympics shakeup. His agent steps up with the inside story on why the veteran netminder sticks with Edmonton through all the drama. Loyalty like this isn't common in a league where goalies get flipped faster than McDavid dangles defenders, and it raises questions about the Oilers' depth chart heading into the stretch run.

NHL analysts are ripping into the Oilers for their risky handling of veteran goalie Calvin Pickard, who just cleared waivers after getting squeezed out of the three-goalie rotation with Tristan Jarry nearing a return and Connor Ingram stealing the show. Pickard's been a locker room favorite through thick and thin, but his sub-.900 save percentage lately has everyone questioning if Edmonton dodged a bullet or just delayed the inevitable goalie crunch.